This website uses cookies to improve functionalities and user experience.
By clicking the "Accept all cookies" button below, you agree to our Cookie Policy
Traditionally marginalized as amateurish and trivial, early modern local chronicles are increasingly recognized as useful windows onto the vernacular knowledge practices of literate citizens. This paper analyses a digitized corpus of 204 Dutch-language chronicles from the Low Countries (1500–1850), in order to identify the motivations and methodologies of these ‘citizen-scientists’. The paper demonstrates that chronicling was a ubiquitous local practice that was driven by a sense of civic duty among community stakeholders. While authors across the social spectrum often employed a ‘modesty topos’ regarding their literary and historical skills, they demonstrated significant confidence in their roles as reliable witnesses of their times. Many chroniclers were well aware of evolving historiographical practic-es in the world of print. They also adopted professional paratextual tools like indices, marginalia, and explicit source citations from printed historical works. Crises often functioned as a catalyst for record-keeping. The number of chronicles surged during periods of political rupture, such as the Dutch Revolt and the Age of Revolutions, when authors sought to ‘archive the present’ and provide an alternative to mainstream discourse. They relied not only on their own observations but also backed these up with copies of relevant written sources. Local chronicles were thus not archaic relics but sophisticated expressions of responsible citizenship. By documenting the intersection of su-pralocal crises and local impact, chroniclers constructed enduring archives intended to preserve communal identity and protect historical truth for future generations.
Competing Histories, Competing Powers: Lay Research, Urban Memory, and Institutional Conflict in Early 18th-Century Paris Guang Yang
In early18th-century Paris, officers of the municipal council (Hôtel de Ville) and the Châtelet vigorously defended their competing jurisdictions through history-writing. The Châtelet’s newly empowered police provoked Commissaire Nicolas Delamare to publish the multi-volume Traité de la Police (1705–1719) as a polemical statement. Drawing on extensive archival and legal sources, Delamare distinguishes sharply between consular jurisdiction, “police particulière” and “police générale”. Under this scheme, the municipal leaders are confined to adjudicating river-trade disputes, while the Châtelet claims the general policing authority. Delamare selectively omits or abbreviates contrary documents (notably the 1672 royal ordinance). Contemporary observers noted that the Traité therefore served not merely as a treatise on urban policing but as a strategic weapon against the city’s claims.
Alarmed by Delamare’s influence, city leaders commissioned a counter-history. In 1725 Michel Félibien and Guy-Alexis Lobineau’s Histoire de la ville de Paris appeared as an authorized response, explicitly defending municipal prerogatives. It opens with Pierre Le Roy’s Dissertation sur l’origine de l’Hôtel de Ville, a rigorous rebuttal to Delamare. Le Roy marshals numerous unpublished charters, registers and early chronicles (collected in a “Recueil de chartes” from the Paris archives). According to the chapter, Le Roy then extends Paris’s origins back to antiquity, arguing that the city inherited the privileges of its ancient nautes (river merchants) from Roman times. Lobineau supplements this with an archaeological element: stone blocks bearing a Roman inscription, found in Notre-Dame in 1711, dedicated to the nautes. From these, he infers that the Parisian municipality was already in place under Emperor Tiberius. The placement of Le Roy’s polemical dissertation at the start of the Histoire was a deliberate strategy to foreground the municipalist thesis.
These rival histories underscore how local history-writing was instrumentalized in an institutional conflict. Both Delamare and the Félibien–Lobineau team exhibit “profound knowledge of ancient titles” and employ meticulous diplomatic and archival methods. The chapter highlights the exceptional richness of sources on both sides—overlooked royal edicts, unpublished registers, medieval charters and contemporary printed accounts. Both works amass an “arsenal of arguments” from this evidence. This case illustrates
Lay Monument Surveyor, or Chronicler of the Past?
Viktor Myskovszyk, Art Teacher in the Service of Monument Protection in 19th-Century Hungary Gábor Papp
My presentation aims to show how lay people in Hungary participated in the research of urban history and architectural history in the mid-19th century. I will show the broader context in which it was natural for members of the lay bourgeoisie to actively participate in discovering the history of the city or founding institutions. The primary task of the Provisional (later National) Committee for Hungarian Monuments, an organization dealing with monuments established in 1872 based on the Austrian model, was to survey and describe the monuments of the past. The lay local patriots who participated in the cataloguing of monuments played a very important role not only in laying the foundations for scientific work on monuments, but also in turning towards the past and shaping the identity of the urban bourgeoisie.
Through the story of Viktor Myskovszky (1838-1909), an art teacher with a degree in architecture I would like to present the role of lay research and its changing role in urban history. For the call of the Committee he compiled and drew the buildings and objects of the cities of Košice, Bardejov, and other cities in present-day Slovakia. More than 700 of his drawings, their documentation, and the on-site sketches that served as the basis for the drawings can now be studied in the former archives of the Committee (Budapest). In my presentation, I will use three monuments (Kassa, Cathedral, St. Michael's Chapel, Bártfa, Town Hall) to illustrate his work and the process by which, from the 1880s onwards, his work came under criticism in line with the changing attitude towards historical monuments. He was criticized for his lack of professionalism: the lack of the accuracy of his measurements already reflected the approach and expectations of a new era.
Based on the examples presented in the lecture, I would like to point out, too, the extent to which the concept of the layman itself can be interpreted in terms of the process of professionalization. I am thinking of how the changing role of the intelligentsia in the second half of the 19th century influenced the relationship to the past. While in mid-19th century Hungary the intelligentsia participated in the exploration of the city's history and the activities of its institutions, by the end of the 19th century the actors of the professional, academic world had to a certain extent monopolized the discourse on the past. This process had important consequences for the scientific approach of the 20th century